Feature story - 6 May, 2002
The European vinyl industry proposes a flawed and inadequate voluntary commitment to deal with PVC pollution says Greenpeace
The industry recently published the second progress report on
its voluntary code of conduct "Vinyl 2010", where it claims to
place strong emphasis on recycling, yet its overall aim is only 7
percent of post consumer waste by 2010.
The industry also supports incinerating remaining waste despite
European Parliament and environmentalist's objections because
incineration creates more pollution.
Incinerating PVC creates dioxins, a known human carcinogen that
world governments have agreed must be eliminated from the
planet.
"The chances of the PVC industry effectively policing itself are
zero. Not only is 'Vinyl 2010' a total waste of time, it is a
cynical attempt to preserve the industry and its profits, despite
overwhelming evidence that the very existence of PVC is damaging
human health and the environment," said Greenpeace campaigner Jorgo
Iwasaki-Riss.
Greenpeace believes the vinyl industry is throwing up a
smokescreen by acting as though the EU has already adopted the
voluntary code. Greenpeace warns the adoption of such a flawed plan
would leave the European Commission with no credibility.
Some of the inadequate suggestions from 'Vinyl 2010' are:
- No greater commitment to address hazardous discharges during
the manufacture of PVC than EU regulations already require;
- No commitment beyond research and risk assessment on
phthalates, despite an EU emergency ban already in place on
phthalates in children toys; and
- A commitment to phase out lead by 2015, despite alternatives
being available now and Sweden succeeding in banning lead
already.
The "Vinyl 2010" initiative completely fails to address the fact
that recycling is not the answer to the problem of PVC. The
continued manufacture, use and disposal of PVC and the raw
materials such as chlorine, that are used in the process, are a
significant threat to health and the environment. Only the full
phase out of PVC and the introduction of sustainable alternatives
will prevent further environmental damage from the vinyl
industry.