Green Energy Act a Trojan horse for building more nuclear reactors: Greenpeace

Press release - April 8, 2009
Greenpeace confronted the nuclear plans of Energy Minister George Smitherman today by parking a billboard in front of Queen’s Park reading: “Minister: Don’t Nuke Green Energy.”

The Greenpeace action is to expose a little known clause in the proposed Green Energy Act that allows Smitherman to indiscriminately build nuclear reactors without any public review of their cost by the Ontario Energy board. Greenpeace wants this disturbing clause removed. Greenpeace believes an independent review of nuclear costs and green options is important because the cost of a new nuclear plant has skyrocketed to $15 billion from $5.8 billion since 2005.

Smitherman is scheduled to address the hearings on the Green Energy Act today. The Greenpeace billboard will remain at Queen's Park for several hours to emphasize this problem with the act. Greenpeace energy campaigner Shawn-Patrick Stensil is also scheduled to speak at the hearings today.

"Smitherman has turned the draft Green Energy Act into a Trojan horse by embedding in it a nuclear clause that will badly undermine the future of green power in Ontario," said Stensil. "Smitherman's plan to build new reactors blocks the development of green energy. A law that gives him the right to build reactors without any public input makes a scary situation even worse."

The McGuinty government has a history of avoiding public review of its nuclear plans. It exempted its electricity plan, including the nuclear plans, from an environmental assessment and won't participate in federal environmental assessments so it can avoid consideration of alternatives to nuclear.

Greenpeace supports the Green Energy Act as a valuable tool for creating a green energy system in Ontario. But Smitherman's decision to reserve 50 per cent of the province's electricity grid for nuclear energy blocks any significant expansion of green power. The Greenpeace billboard has a caricature of Smitherman pouring nuclear waste on to a windmill.

"Smitherman really will be Ontario's Nuclear Energy Minister if he doesn't amend the act and say no to new reactors," said Stensil. "The Green Energy Act will be nothing but a diversion if the Trojan horse remains to support the government's nuclear agenda."

Smitherman has said he will announce the government's decision on whether to rebuild the Pickering nuclear station or replace it with new reactors in June. Greenpeace's campaign is to convince Smitherman to replace the Pickering reactors with green energy when they reach the end of their operational lives beginning in 2013.

A report endorsed by Canada's major environmental organizations in November shows that the only way the government can expand green energy is by replacing ageing nuclear stations, starting with the Pickering reactors, with new green energy sources over the decade.

"Ontarians want more green power and less nuclear power," said Stensil. "If he made a decision this summer to replace the Pickering reactors with green energy, Smitherman could prove his commitment to green power and prove that the McGuinty government really wants to be North America's green energy leader.

- 30 -

For more information, please contact:

Brian Blomme, Communications Coordinator, (416) 930-9055

Shawn-Patrick Stensil, Energy Campaigner, (416) 884-7053