Illegal e-waste exposed

Feature Story - 2008-06-14
A container of electronic waste (e-waste) from the port of Oakland in the United States was intercepted in Hong Kong by Greenpeace activists. After months of research, we determined that the container was destined for Sanshui district in mainland China meaning that - under Chinese law - the import was illegal. Activists boarded the YM Success, pitched a tent on top of the containers and prevented the illegal e-waste from being offloaded.

A Greenpeace activist hangs a banner on a container ship recently arrived from the USA carrying toxic e-waste, Hong Kong, 14 June 2008.The Hong Kong Environmental Protection Department and the Hong Kong Customs have agreed to the demand of Greenpeace and put the containers on hold as a direct result of the action.

We urged the Hong Kong authorities to take action by refusing the entry of the container and to send it back to the US. Banners made our message clear: "Toxic waste not welcomed here." The captain of the ship agreed not to offload the container until the Hong Kong authorities investigate the legality.

Earlier this year, we asked the question, "Where does all the e-waste go?". On this occasion, we were able to find out exactly where it was going – but this is only the tip of an enormous e-waste iceberg, regularly and illegally entering mainland China due to to loopholes in Hong Kong's legislation.

According to Hong Kong's Waste Disposal Ordinance, only batteries and cathode ray tubes are banned from import, but there is no clear legislation to guard against other electronic waste and their by-products entering Hong Kong's ports. Irresponsible e-waste traders exploit this loophole and the island has become a transit point for e-waste destined for Mainland China as well as other developing countries.

When workers in the so-called "informal" recycling centres break electronic devices up so they can recover valuable metals, they are exposed to the hazardous chemical substances contained in most electronic equipment. This toxic cocktail not only threatens human health; it also pollutes the water, soil and air of the surrounding environment.

Electronics are increasingly becoming part of the "throw away" culture in many developed countries. Few electronic devices are designed to be upgrade-able, and because they are made with hazardous materials – including toxic heavy metals, phthalates, polyvinyl chloride and brominated flame retardants – recycling is not always a safe and easy option.

Every year, some 20 to 50 million tonnes of dangerous e-waste are generated worldwide. While some can be accounted for in general household waste or landfills, some end up – often illegally, as is the case here – in the scrap yards and dumping grounds of developing countries in Asia and Africa.

In the US it is still legal to export collected e-waste to Asia and Africa. In the European Union, e-waste is regulated by EU and national law. But, even in countries with regulations there is a surprisingly large amount of e-waste that is not captured by producer responsibility programmes or take-back schemes.

Ultimately, the principle of producer responsibility is key to solving this problem. This principle requires that the manufacturers of electronics devices take the financial and management responsibilities for what happens to their own end-of-life products. Companies like Sony, Samsung and Nokia have introduced take-back schemes, but there are many other major companies that still need to follow this example. Some maintain that it is their customers' responsibility to pay for the costs of recycling e-waste.

And, by phasing-out the use of toxic chemicals in electronics devices at the design stage of a product's life, manufacturers make it safer to recycle e-waste and reduce their own costs for dealing with their end-of-life products. What greater incentive could they want?

Manufacturers need to implement toxic-free design and bring green electronics onto the markets, and introduce take-back schemes to responsibly recycle or dispose of their products when they reach the end of their life. For as long as electronics manufacturers fail to live up to their responsibilities, e-waste will continue to flow to places.

It's time to turn the tide.

Categories