The Noose Tightens: Bhopal Court Issues Notice to Dow in Criminal Case

Feature story - January 12, 2005
BHOPAL, India — The Chief Judicial Magistrate of the Bhopal Court has ordered that a letter rogatory be sent to the United States Department of Justice to request them, in the interest of justice, to serve a summons on the head quarters of Dow Chemical Corporation at Midland Michigan, USA. For the first time, Dow Chemicals is directly named in the criminal trial in India in connection with the 1984 Bhopal disaster - a milestone for the campaign for justice in Bhopal.

Bhopal. Living poisoned daily courtesy DOW.

On the 6th of January 2005, in a significant step for the campaign for justice in Bhopal, the Chief Judicial Magistrate of Bhopal, Mr. Anil Kumar Gupta, ordered "a notice to be issued (through the appropriate legal procedure) to Dow Chemical Corporation, Midland, Michigan, USA". The order came in response to an application filed by the Bhopal Group for Information and Action, that held that Dow Chemicals as the sole owner of Union Carbide Corporation (UCC), should be required to ensure that the "absconding accused UCC" be present in the ongoing criminal trial in the Bhopal court.

The court will now proceed to issue a letter Rogatory to the United States Department of Justice to request them, in the interest of justice, to serve a summons on the head quarters of Dow Chemical Corporation at Midland Michigan, USA.

For the first time, Dow Chemicals is directly named in the criminal trial in India in connection with the 1984 Bhopal disaster. This is a serious blow to the company, which has, against massive public pressure, still held on to its lies. Despite taking over UCC's assets, they have held that they are in no way accountable for its liabilities. In the words of Dow's own spokesperson John Musser, "There is no legal foundation for application of liability. Union Carbide resolved their liability in regards to the Bhopal tragedy, so when we purchased their shares, there was no liability left." "This is a significant step forward towards finally compelling Union Carbide to address its unresolved criminal liability for the Bhopal disaster in keeping with the final orders of the Indian Supreme Court in this case. Now, it is time for Dow Chemical and Union Carbide to defend their repeated public protestations of innocence before a court of law. The refusal to appear in response to this lawful summons should speak volumes to the world about the truth of the frivolous claims and arguments that they have been repeating for the past 20 years." said Rajan Sharma, a New York-based lawyer representing the survivors in a class action suit against UCC in the United States.

Dow would now have to explain why it shouldn't be required to produce Union Carbide to face trial in Bhopal and allow for the resolution of long pending criminal case. If Dow fails to respond, it runs the risk of being accused of sheltering a fugitive. This could possibly place Dow's Indian assets in jeopardy, harm future business plans in India, apart from seriously affecting its reputation in the world.

Greenpeace has been campaigning against Dow worldwide along with Bhopal survivors groups to tell them that they can never run away from the legacies they have inherited and by their inaction, contributed to.

Scientific analysis of samples of soil and water collected in and around the factory by Greenpeace in 1999 and 2002 has revealed severe chemical contamination in the area. The chemicals discovered by the investigation are toxins that are known to be injurious to the central nervous system, liver, kidneys as well as other organs. The Carbide factory grounds in Bhopal are to this day strewn with hundreds of tonnes of dangerous chemicals that are not safely contained. These, and other chemicals from Union Carbide's earlier operations have poisoned the soil and groundwater in this part of the city where more than 20,000 people live - guaranteeing them a life that is poisoned daily. Every year that Dow delays action the contamination becomes more deadly and critical.

The honourable court's decision endorses what Greenpeace and the other groups have been saying all along. Dow cannot wish away its pending liabilities in Bhopal. The earlier they acknowledge the writing on the wall the better", says Vinuta Gopal of Greenpeace India. At least one person a day still dies from gas exposure related diseases and 150,000 are in urgent need of medical attention. Hundreds of families living near the site still routinely use the poisoned water.

The noose is slowly and surely tightening around Dow's neck. Not long ago, on the 20th anniversary of the Bhopal disaster, BBC ran an interview with someone falsely claiming to be a Dow Chemical official who said Dow had taken responsibility for the disaster. It seems like the day they would be forced to do so is not far away.

Read the Order

Categories