Deal brokeredTraditionally,
this sort of thing is smoothed over beforehand. However, this time
governments kept fighting publicly until this afternoon. In the end,
the divisions got papered over with rhetoric. Most likely the
politicians feel quite satisfied at having avoided a public
disagreement. But the differences remain obvious for all to see.
The final document agreed by the G8 also contains a promise that all
leaders will "seriously consider" the binding emission cuts the EU and
almost all G8 members have committed to. In other words, Bush will
watch, while the rest of the world, hopefully, acts.
The
deal is "clearly not enough to prevent dangerous climate change" said
Daniel Mittler, climate policy advisor of Greenpeace International at
the summit. "Governments failed to commit to what science tells us is
necessary here. They must now urgently do so at the United Nations."
What
these leaders, of the world's wealthiest nations, fail to take into
account is that reducing CO2 emissions by 50 percent, compared to 1990
levels, by 2050 is not a negotiable diplomatic point - it is a physical
reality. And, as we’ve already learned from the last 15 years,
voluntary measures simply don't work.
Politics aside, the G8 are
responsible for over 80 percent of the climate change we witness today,
and still emit over 40 percent of all global emissions. They are
therefore morally bound to act first and act firmly.
Silver lining in a cloudy skyThe
isolation of the US on climate change was at least further exposed
through this whole process - leaving the Bush Administration scrambling
for diversionary tactics.
Today's document also confirms that
the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change is the best
way forward, which sets back Bush's plan for a US controlled parallel
process. This means, that the road is clear for real negotiations on
binding emission cuts to start in earnest at the next climate meeting
in Bali in December this year.
Though as Greenpeace UK director
John Sauven pointed out, "Scientists tell us we need to slash emissions
over the next decade if we're to have a chance of preventing dangerous
climate change. This document acknowledges the seriousness of the
situation then ducks reality by offering weasel words like 'seriously
considering', as if this was an after dinner discussion rather than the
most important issue facing the world."
Into the exclusion zoneTens
of thousands of people have been peacefully protesting these past days,
both at Heiligendamm and at an alternative summit - trying to get the
message through to the G8 that the time to act is now.
Yesterday,
German police pre-emptively boarded our ship, the Arctic Sunrise - even
though it was well outside the summit's exclusion zone. The police came
on without a search warrant and confined the 24 crew before seizing
Greenpeace equipment including engines from inflatables, making the
boats unusable, and the hull of a Greenpeace hot air balloon.
This
morning, 24 Greenpeace activists, using 11 speedboats took the message
"G8: Act Now!" to the waters around the beachfront summit hotel. They
entered the outer restricted area at 11am, informing the police as they
did so. They came in from both east and west sides, entering into the
inner restricted zone 10 minutes later.
Police boats ran over
some of the Greenpeace boats - injuring six activists and sending
several to the hospital. Fortunately, no one suffered more than severe
bruising. The activists were trying to deliver a petition calling for
clear commitments on climate change.
At last report, the boats and 19 activists were in police custody.
The
next major UN Climate Conference will be in Bali, Indonesia, December
2007. Governments there must commit to the reductions that science
requires, to stop catastrophic climate change.
-- More updates and background on our G8 page --