US court ruling on GMO rice affirms danger of Bayer crops

Greenpeace pushes for ruling on motion in RP court

Press release - December 9, 2009
A United States federal jury ruling on 4 December 2009, that Bayer CropScience LP must pay US$2 million to two Missouri farmers, affirms that the responsibility for the consequences of contamination from genetically modified organisms (GMO) rests with the company that releases GMO crops. The Missouri farmers’ crops were contaminated with an experimental variety of rice that Bayer was testing in 2006. Greenpeace welcomed the verdict, pointing out that there is no legal GMO rice currently grown in the world and Bayer’s application for commercialisation in the Philippines and in certain other parts of the world is mainly to legalise the entry of contaminated rice from the US where massive contamination was discovered in 2006.

A motion for reconsideration has been filed by Greenpeace last November 25 with the Philippine Court of Appeals (CA), in relation to the decision to dismiss the temporary writ of injunction preventing the Department of Agriculture - Bureau of Plant Industry from approving Bayer's genetically modified rice, LL62, for importation as food, feed and processing, in the Philippines.

"The CA's decision undermines the right of Filipinos, whose staple food is rice, to consume food that is safe and free from GMO-contamination," said Danny Ocampo, Sustainable Agriculture Campaigner of Greenpeace Southeast Asia. "Aside from the risks involved in the process of developing this genetically modified rice strain, residues of the powerful herbicide -- Liberty Link (glufosinate) -- also put at risk those who will be consuming it on a daily basis and at least 2 times a day. GMO rice should never be allowed to enter Philippine shores again and threaten our rice supply in the future."

Bayer has admitted it has been unable to control the spread of its genetically-engineered organisms despite 'the best practices' to stop contamination[1]. It shows that all outdoors field trials or commercial growing of GMO crops must be stopped before our crops are irreversibly contaminated.

A report prepared for Greenpeace International concluded that the total costs incurred throughout the world as a result of the contamination are estimated to range from 741 million to 1.285 billion US dollars.[2] The verdict indicates that Bayer is liable for what could turn out to be a large proportion of these costs, as it awards damages in the first two of more than 1,200 currently pending lawsuits. The decision must be used to support all claims for losses incurred by other US farmers whose crops have suffered from GMO contamination.

Other contacts: Daniel Ocampo, Sustainable Agriculture Campaigner, +63917 8976416, (632) 4146512 loc 112, JP Agcaoili, Media Campaigner, +63917 6312750, (632) 414 6512 loc 121,

Notes: [1] Bayers Defense lawyer, Mark Ferguson as reported in Harris, A. 2009. Bayer Blamed at Trial for Crops ‘Contaminated’ by Modified Rice. Bloomberg News 4th November 2009, available at: [2] E.N. Blue (2007) Risky Business. Economic and regulatory impacts from the unintended release of genetically engineered rice varieties into the rice merchandising system of the US. Report prepared for Greenpeace International, available online at