Oil company polluters, not taxpayers and farmers, should bear responsibility for cleaning up the leftover toxic sites oil companies leave behind.
Tomorrow, Greenpeace Canada’s lawyer will defend the “polluter pays” principle in a case being heard by the Supreme Court of Canada.
The decision in the case (Orphan Well Association, et al. v. Grant Thornton Limited, et al.) will determine whether or not oil and gas, forestry or mining companies that go bankrupt will be able to prioritize paying back bankers by selling off valuable assets, while leaving taxpayers and landowners on the hook to clean up the environmental mess they leave behind.
This legal battle began when Calgary-based oil and gas company, Redwater Energy Corp, went bankrupt. Its bankruptcy trustee wanted to abandon the wells that were expensive to remediate (clean up), while selling the profitable wells to pay off Redwater’s ’s creditors. The Alberta Energy Regulator (AER) challenged this decision, arguing that the company should set aside money to meet the expected costs of remediation. The AER is responsible for ensuring the safety and environmentally responsible development of the province’s energy resources.
In a controversial decision, the Alberta Court of Appeal determined that payment to creditors (under federal bankruptcy law) supersedes insolvent companies’ clean-up obligations under provincial environmental law. This meant that the Redwater’s bankruptcy trustee (Grant Thornton) could do what it wanted.
With billions of dollars at stake, the AER has now taken the issue to the country’s highest court. The Supreme Court has agreed to re-examine the decision. The hearing will take place tomorrow.
Since the Redwater decision in Alberta, more than 1,800 hundred wells representing $100 million-plus in liabilities have been abandoned.
Thousands of abandoned (orphaned) oil wells are littered across Alberta’s landscape, threatening to contaminate water and soil or leak dangerous gases that endanger families in nearby homes. The social costs of dealing with these liabilities could total $8 billion.
The outcome of this case will set an important precedent.
The decision will determine whether polluters can shirk their environmental clean-up responsibilities and at a higher level, clarify how provincial environmental regulations can be squared with federal bankruptcy laws.
We don’t want a future where bankrupt oil, mining or logging companies can ignore environmental regulations and walk away from their clean-up obligations without so much as a second glance. Worse yet, they could purposely exploit these laws to avoid their environmental obligations.
This is an urgent issue, for as Canada moves towards a low-carbon future in line with the commitments we made under the Paris climate agreement, fossil fuel companies that fail to adapt are at increased risk of bankruptcy. Greenpeace is saying that if companies aren’t prepared to be part of the climate solution, then the public shouldn’t be on the hook for cleaning up their mess. It should be the polluter that pays.
We are honoured to be an intervenor in this case. For us, this means that this country’s highest court believes we have a valuable expertise that should be heard and we intend to fulfill our responsibility to Canadians to bring that expertise to bear.
You can read our legal argument on the Supreme Court of Canada website.
Discussion
Greatest news for all us
<b>Name fresh</b> supplements to enormous orgasms - larger well greater powerful climaxes! <b>no witnessed</b> formerly - exceptionally current within healing discipline investigation! <b>Completely secure</b> well powerful - too elevated drive plus yet elevated sexual rigidity! <a href="https://psee.io/7qlgd7" rel="nofollow ugc"><b>Raise size of individual discharges instantly right now!</b></a>
Visualize coming home to find leak spreading through the rooms belongings and family treasures. It’s stressful — but you don’t have to face it alone. We’re here to preserve your house and loved ones’ well-being acting quickly and carefully to contain the problem at once. Our team works with gentleness and protection helping recover your space and your comfort. We help you stop mold and long-term consequences ensuring a healthier space for your loved ones. And with our 24/7 support you’re never without help when it matters most — we’re always ready to step in Call - 8338561951 and professionals will help you
Personally realize the way scary this strikes whenever moisture places their dwelling along with household’s comfort toward danger. But you remain in no way isolated. We remain around so as to preserve yours property together with this kindness belonging to one’s household lifestyle functioning attentively as well as harmlessly so that everything you cherish stays whole. Such squad acts immediately to halt destruction as well as avert mildew giving one peace belonging to thought. Furthermore with the 24/7 service somebody always get a partner close to the presence — set aiming to aid you sustain their relatives safe as well as the residence occupied through comfort. Find peace in your home - Call: 8338561951
Myself understand the method intimidating that comes across at the moment liquid causes one’s dwelling along with relatives’ security into hazard. Yet you are never by yourself. We remain around aiming to shield the dwelling together with this comfort of one’s family life working attentively together with soundly so that the whole one cherish stays secure. This team operates rapidly to halt damage and avert fungus giving you peace relating to awareness. Furthermore together with the 24/7 help somebody forever have someone next to yours presence — willing in order to aid somebody sustain the loved ones guarded and the home full in security. Find peace in your home - Call: 8338561951