How the Science Committee’s Exxon Charade Distracts From Real Science

by Naomi Ages

September 15, 2016

Instead of taking on any of the work that the chairman of the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology could do to address the catastrophic effects that climate change will have on the people of the U.S., Representative Smith has decided the best move is to invite fossil fuel-funded witnesses to support his meritless efforts.

Rep. Peter Welch, D-Vermont, speaks at a Press Conference at the Capitol in Washington, D.C. Speakers condemned the move by House Science, Space and Technology committee chair Rep. Lamar Smith, R-Texas, to hold a hearing on his power to issue and enforce subpoenas against non-governmental group and the attorneys general of two states seeking emails about investigations of Exxon Mobil related to climate change denial.

An #ExxonKnew coalition press conference calls out the House Science, Space and Technology committee hearing on Wednesday.

Do you love charades? I do. But I play it on my own time, for entertainment purposes. Yesterday, Representative Lamar Smith (R-TX) put together one of the biggest charades we’ve seen, disguised as a Congressional hearing.

Representative Smith used our tax dollars to call politicians and legal scholars to protect Exxon Mobil from being investigated for potential fraud.

Rep. Smith claimed that the purpose of his charade was to investigate the House Committee on Science, Space and Technology’s — which he chairs — ability to investigate the investigations. If that makes any sense, he called the hearing shortly after he served the subpoenas on the Attorneys General of New York and Massachusetts, who are investigating whether Exxon committed fraud by keeping relevant information on the risks of climate change from its shareholders and the public – potentially violating state laws.

Those subpoenas were also served on non-governmental organizations that have worked extensively to uncover and publicize Exxon’s massive climate denial scheme.

None of the parties served with the subpoenas complied.

Smith’s move backfired because it is basically bullying to protect the interests of Exxon and other big oil and gas companies.

Instead of taking on any of the work that the chairman of the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology could do to address the catastrophic effects that climate change will have on the people of the U.S., Smith has decided the best move was to invite fossil-fuel-funded witnesses to support his meritless effort.

Let’s be clear: Lamar Smith has taken almost $700,000 from the fossil fuel industry and he is now using his political influence to prevent a giant oil and gas company from being investigated for potential fraud.

While Smith and friends were commending each other — for basically putting corporate interests over the people — the very fact that there was no vote or internal bipartisan discussion by the Committee before serving the subpoenas was barely addressed.

Another major thing missing in the discussion was Smith and friends’ hypocrisy in claiming to be standing up for scientists. No one who got a subpoena is attacking science, or scientists. Greenpeace fully supports scientists! But let’s be clear: The attorneys general of New York and Massachusetts are investigating Exxon for potentially covering up its own scientists’ research to avoid regulations and protect profits. The NGOs are calling for Exxon to be held accountable for denying climate change. Meanwhile, Lamar Smith has been attacking science and scientists for years. On the taxpayers’ dime.

Rep. Bill Foster (D-Il) said it clearly: “I hope this hearing is not another gigantic waste of time and taxpayer money”. I shared the hope, but that’s unlikely.

This is why thousands of people are calling on the Department of Justice to open an investigation on Exxon’s climate denial.

The people of the United States deserve to know the truth about climate denial, and we also deserve a better future. Our livelihoods shouldn’t have to suffer from runaway climate change that corporations like Exxon denied for years.

Join us! Call on the Department of Justice to investigate Exxon for undermining climate science and climate action.

Naomi Ages

By Naomi Ages

Naomi Ages is a senior political strategist with Greenpeace International.

We Need Your Voice. Join Us!

Want to learn more about tax-deductible giving, donating stock and estate planning?

Visit Greenpeace Fund, a nonprofit, 501(c)(3) charitable entity created to increase public awareness and understanding of environmental issues through research, the media and educational programs.